Integrity Evaluation in Conservation of Amir-chakhmagh Square in Yazd, Iran

نوع مقاله: مقاله پژوهشی

نویسندگان

1 Assistant Professor of Architecture, Department of Architectural & Urban Heritage Conservation, College of Fine Arts, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran.

2 Professor of Architecture, Department of Architectural & Urban Heritage Conservation, College of Fine Arts, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran.

چکیده

The concept of integrity, as a factor which sustains values and significance of cultural
heritage, is regarded as a key criterion in the process of urban heritage conservation and thus, the need for
clarification of its factors has been emphasized in the international conventions, documents and scientific
papers. Review and analysis of documents, conventions and theories concerning the role of integrity in
urban heritage conservation show that in recent decades, the concept of integrity has attracted worldwide
attention in the process of selection, assessment, and codification of the comprehensive conservation
and management plan of urban heritage. This paper aims to recognize the aspects of integrity concept
and tries to refine the prioritization of integrity aspects in the plans and measures of Amir-chakhmagh
Square conservation project in Yazd, Iran. To achieve this aim, firstly the conventions and the scientific
papers related to integrity are reviewed; consequently the effective aspects in measuring integrity have
been selected in three main categories: ‘Structural-historical Integrity’, ‘Functional-social Integrity’, and
‘Visual-aesthetic Integrity’. Thereafter, the prioritizing of these aspects in the Amir-chakhmagh Square
conservation is analyzed by quantitative research method and correlation strategy. The findings indicate
that the ‘Functional-social Integrity’, ‘Structural-historical Integrity’ and ‘Visual-aesthetic Integrity’, in
descending order, have the highest to the lowest contribution to explaining the concept of integrity in the
measures taken for Amir-chakhmagh Square conservation project. This indicates the measures have
been successful in terms of reviving the social vitality of the square and refurbing the historic
buildings around the square by adaptive reuse. Finally, findings from quantitative measurements confirm
the theoretical framework of the research which is provided by Jokilehto.

کلیدواژه‌ها


عنوان مقاله [English]

Integrity Evaluation in Conservation of Amir-chakhmagh Square in Yazd, Iran

نویسندگان [English]

  • Somayeh Fadaei Nezhad Bahramjerdi 1
  • Pirouz Hanachi 2
1 Assistant Professor of Architecture, Department of Architectural & Urban Heritage Conservation, College of Fine Arts, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran.
2 Professor of Architecture, Department of Architectural & Urban Heritage Conservation, College of Fine Arts, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran.
چکیده [English]

The concept of integrity, as a factor which sustains values and significance of cultural
heritage, is regarded as a key criterion in the process of urban heritage conservation and thus, the need for
clarification of its factors has been emphasized in the international conventions, documents and scientific
papers. Review and analysis of documents, conventions and theories concerning the role of integrity in
urban heritage conservation show that in recent decades, the concept of integrity has attracted worldwide
attention in the process of selection, assessment, and codification of the comprehensive conservation
and management plan of urban heritage. This paper aims to recognize the aspects of integrity concept
and tries to refine the prioritization of integrity aspects in the plans and measures of Amir-chakhmagh
Square conservation project in Yazd, Iran. To achieve this aim, firstly the conventions and the scientific
papers related to integrity are reviewed; consequently the effective aspects in measuring integrity have
been selected in three main categories: ‘Structural-historical Integrity’, ‘Functional-social Integrity’, and
‘Visual-aesthetic Integrity’. Thereafter, the prioritizing of these aspects in the Amir-chakhmagh Square
conservation is analyzed by quantitative research method and correlation strategy. The findings indicate
that the ‘Functional-social Integrity’, ‘Structural-historical Integrity’ and ‘Visual-aesthetic Integrity’, in
descending order, have the highest to the lowest contribution to explaining the concept of integrity in the
measures taken for Amir-chakhmagh Square conservation project. This indicates the measures have
been successful in terms of reviving the social vitality of the square and refurbing the historic
buildings around the square by adaptive reuse. Finally, findings from quantitative measurements confirm
the theoretical framework of the research which is provided by Jokilehto.

کلیدواژه‌ها [English]

  • Integrity
  • Conservation
  • evaluation
  • Amir-chakhmagh Square
  • Yazd
  • Iran

Barati, N., Davoudpour, Z., & Montazeri, M. (2012).

Research Method in Environmental Studies. Tehran:

Sakoo, 102-108.

Declaration of Quebec. (2008). Declaration on

the Preservation of the Spirit of Place. Available at:

https://whc.unesco.org/uploads/activities/documents/

activity-646-2.pdf, Accessed on May 2010.

English Heritage. (2008). Conservation Principles:

Policies and Guidance for the Sustainable Management

of the Historic Environment. English Heritage, London.

Fadaei Nezhad, S., Eshrati, P., & Eshrati, D. (2015).

Developing a Conceptual Framework for Integrity in

Urban Heritage Conservation. Armanshahr Journal

Architecture & Urban Development, 9(16), 96-104.

Gullino, P., & Larcher, F. (2013). Integrity in

UNESCO World Heritage Sites. A Comparative Study

for Rural Landscapes. Journal of Cultural Heritage, 14,

389-395.

Heidari, Sh. (2014). An Introduction to Architectural

Research. Tehran: Fekreno Book.

Heike, C.A., & Hazen, H.D. (2010). Maintaing

Authenticity and Integrity at Cultural World Heritage

Sites, Geographical Review, 100 (1), 56-73.

ICCROM. (2007). Sharing, Conservation, Decisions.

Rome, Italy.

ICOMOS. (1964). International Charter for the

Conservation and Restoration of Monuments and

Sites (The Venice Charter). Available at: http: //www.

international. icomos.org/ centre_documentation/

chartes_eng.htm. Accessed on May 2008.

ICOMOS Charter. (1994). The Nara Conference

on Authenticity in Relation to the World Heritage

Convention. Available at: http://icomos. org/index. php/

en/charters-and-texts, Accessed: May 2010.

ICOMOS Charter. (2008). Charter on Cultural

Routes. Available at: http://www. icomos. org/index. php/

en/charters-and-texts, Accessed: May 2010.

Jokilehto, J. (2006). Considerations on Authenticity

and Integrity in World Heritage Context. City & Time,

2(1), 1.

Khademzadeh, M. (2012). Oral Interview. Project

Manager of the Amir-chakgmagh Square. Place of

Interview: University of Tehran.

Mandeghari, K. (2012). Oral Interview. Place of

Interview: University of Yazd.

Pendlebury. J., Short. M., & Aidan W. (2009). Urban

World Heritage Sites and the Problem of Authenticity.

Cities, 26, 349–358.

Rossler, M. (2008). Applying Authenticity to Cultural

Landscapes. In Waite, Diana. (Ed.), APT Bulletin,

XXXIX (2-3), 47-54. Published by Association for

Preservation Technology International.

Shabestan Consulting Engineers. (2011).

Reorganization Plan of Seyed Mostafa Khomeini Square

(Shah Tahmasb, Beasat) of Yazd. General Studies of the

Formation of the Plan; Employer: Yazd Municipality,

Department of Planning and Architecture.

Stovel, H. (2007). Effective Use of Authenticity and

Integrity as World Heritage Qualifying Conditions. City

& Time, 2(3), 3.

UNESCO World Heritage Centre and City of Vienna.

(2005). Proceedings of the International Conference

“World Heritage and Contemporary Architecture –

Managing the Historic Urban Landscape”. Vienna: City

of Vienna.

UNESCO. (2005). Operational Guidelines for the

Implementation of the World Heritage Convention. World

Heritage Committee and World Heritage Centre.

UNESCO. (2011). Operational Guidelines for the

Implementation of the World Heritage Convention. Paris:

World Heritage Centre.

UNESCO. (2011). Recommendation on the Historic

Urban Landscape (Draft) Adopted by the General

Conference at its 36th Session. Paris: UNESCO World

Heritage Centre.

Wang,Y., Huang, S., & Kyoungjin, K.A. (2015).

Toward a Framework Integrating Authenticity and

Integrity in Heritage Tourism. Journal of Sustainable

Tourism, 23(10), 1468-1481.

Zancheti, S.M., & Hidaka, L.T.F. (2011). Measuring

Urban Heritage Conservation: Theory and Structure.

Journal of Cultural Heritage Management and

Sustainable Development, 1(2).